The Knicks trailed by 22 points midway through the fourth quarter of Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. They had shot 2-of-19 from three in the first half. They had gone six for the entire third quarter from the field. They had watched Cleveland build a 20-point third-quarter lead from a position of complete offensive control, Mitchell weaving through New York's defense coast to coast for his sixth steal of the game, the Garden going quiet in a way it almost never does. Then Jalen Brunson personally scored 11 consecutive Knicks points to start the comeback. Then Mikal Bridges hit a corner three. Then Landry Shamet tied it with 45 seconds left. Then Harden hit a turnaround jumper to go back up two with 31 seconds. Then Brunson answered with a floating bank shot to tie it again with 19 seconds left. Then Sam Merrill missed a potential winner at the buzzer. Then overtime. Then the Knicks scored the first nine points of the extra period and never looked back. New York 115, Cleveland 104. The largest comeback in Knicks playoff history. A 1-0 series lead. Eight straight wins.

NBA Top Shot's playoff prediction game is live — head to nbatopshot.com/playoffs to get in on the action.

Here's how it works: wager your spendable credits on playoff outcomes to earn more. Miss your prediction? No sweat — your credits come back to you. Hit? Stack 'em up and redeem for packs, Moments, or merch at nbatopshot.com/playoffs/store.

Review your outcomes, check your credits, and redeploy them the next day (max 1,000 per day). Whether you “load the boat” with your top convictions, or spread out your plays, the goal is to maximize your credits each day.

Consistency will be key in earning credits toward the various rewards. But there are also other opportunities to earn credits to capture the rewards in the store.

New York Knicks 115, Cleveland Cavaliers 104 (OT)

The first half told two stories simultaneously. The Knicks led by as many as 11, dominating the paint 32-16 and controlling every physical battle in the first quarter behind Hart's spark and Jordan Clarkson's first three-pointer of the playoffs. But they shot 2-of-19 from three — a rate that in any other context would end any serious playoff conversation — and Cleveland clawed back entirely through Mitchell. He scored seven of Cleveland's points in a 21-8 closing run that gave the Cavaliers a two-point halftime lead, draining a contested three as the buzzer sounded in a moment that silenced MSG completely. Cleveland led 53-51. Mitchell had 16 at the half on nine shots. The Knicks had 35 misses from three-point range through two quarters and were still in the game only because they'd buried Cleveland in the paint.

The third quarter was Cleveland's. They came out of the locker room and ran everything through Mitchell and Harden — Harden finding driving lanes with unusual ease, Mitchell reaching six steals with a coast-to-coast layup that elicited a resigned Mike Breen call — and pushed the lead to 16 at its peak during the period. The Knicks made just six field goals in the third quarter. Brunson didn't make a field goal from the end of the second quarter through most of the fourth. New York's three-point shooting, still broken, compounded everything. Towns was held in check. Bridges was quiet. The Cavaliers were in complete control of every element that defines a road playoff win.

Then the fourth quarter devolved into the kind of chaos that Madison Square Garden was built to produce. Cleveland's offense stalled without warning — the wall that Atkinson could see arriving but couldn't stop — and Brunson took it upon himself. He scored 11 consecutive Knicks points during a stretch that brought New York from down 22 to down five in what felt like three minutes of basketball. The Garden, which had spent the third quarter sitting in uncomfortable silence, came back louder than it had been all night. Bridges hit a corner three with 1:15 remaining to make it a one-possession game. Then Shamet — inserted into the lineup for the game's final stretch — caught at the top of the key and buried a three with 45 seconds left to tie it at 101. Harden answered with a turnaround jump shot with 31 seconds remaining — 103-101, the kind of seasoned veteran midrange that looked like a dagger. Then Brunson drove, floated, and banked in a runner with 19 seconds left to tie it again at 103. Merrill, who had been Cleveland's most dangerous shooter all series against Detroit, had a clear look at a game-winner. It was off the mark. Overtime.

The Knicks scored the first nine points. Anunoby hit two free throws immediately. Brunson drove for a layup. The building, already electric, became uncontainable. Cleveland never led in overtime and the final margin — 115-104 — was a comfortable ending to a game that had nothing comfortable about it for 43 minutes. Brunson finished with 38 points and 6 assists on 15-of-29 from the field, carrying the offensive burden through the stretches when the Knicks' three-point shooting was historically absent and delivering the precise combination of creation and clutch production that makes him the most valuable player in the Eastern Conference. Towns had 20 points and 10 rebounds after being held to just 4 points in the first half. Bridges added 17. Hart contributed 14 with the spark-plug energy off ball screens that Cleveland had no clean defensive answer for in overtime.

Mitchell led Cleveland with 29 points on 12-of-23 and five rebounds — his best individual performance against New York this series. Mobley posted 15 points and 14 rebounds in a physically dominant game that should have produced a win. Harden had 15 points but went 1-of-8 from three and was less decisive driving than the early moments of the game suggested he would be. The Cavaliers had an 18-point lead with six minutes left and scored nine points in the final seven minutes of regulation. That collapse — following the pattern of Cleveland's worst fourth-quarter moments against Detroit — is the conversation heading into Game 2 Thursday.

NYK leads series 1-0. Game 2 is Thursday at Madison Square Garden.

NYK 115 · CLE 104 (OT)

The theme of these playoffs, now fully visible across six weeks of basketball, is that the teams built around multiple legitimate stars performing in the same game at the same time are the ones advancing. Cleveland's Game 7 against Detroit produced four 20-point scorers. San Antonio's Game 1 against OKC produced Wembanyama and Harper simultaneously. New York's comeback produced Brunson carrying the load — but what made it sustainable was Towns, Bridges, and Hart all contributing in overtime. The formula is not one player. The formula is all of them, at the right moment.

Game 1s are in the books and the Spurs & Knicks have the early lead.

Stud of the Day: Jalen Brunson, New York Knicks — 38 points, 6 assists, 11 consecutive personal points during the comeback from 22 down, and the floating bank shot with 19 seconds left that tied the game after Harden had put Cleveland back up two. He didn't make a field goal for most of the third quarter and most of the fourth until the moment the game required him to. Then he scored 11 straight. Then he tied it with a runner in traffic. Then he opened overtime. He is the best closer in the Eastern Conference and Tuesday he proved it against the team that has given him the most trouble this postseason.

Dud of the Night: Cleveland Cavaliers (team) — They led by 22 midway through the fourth quarter of a road conference finals game and scored nine points in the final seven minutes of regulation. The wall is real and it keeps appearing in the same moments. Harden went 1-of-8 from three. Mitchell's 29 points deserved a win. Mobley's 14 rebounds deserved a win. The fourth-quarter execution did not deserve a win and it didn't get one. Game 2 Thursday is the most important early-series game of the East Finals.